No holiday feast feels complete without an impressive selection of homemade pies, and this roundup of Thanksgiving favorites has something for every dessert lover.
Whether you prefer timeless family classics or creative new flavors, these recipes are guaranteed to become the highlight of your holiday table.
As colorful autumn leaves cover the ground and friends and family gather together, there’s nothing quite like ending a meal with a slice of warm, homemade pie.
From rich, creamy creations to fruit-filled favorites, these desserts capture everything we love about the holiday season.
Of course, you’ll find beloved classics like pumpkin pie, pecan pie, and apple pie, but there’s plenty more to explore.
Discover decadent butterscotch pie, tangy cherry pie, silky pudding pies, creamy cheesecakes, and recipes featuring flavorful homemade pie filling that will have everyone asking for seconds.
If you’re searching for the best pie to serve at your holiday gathering, you’ll also find plenty of options beyond the traditional menu. Some recipes feature a flaky homemade crust recipe, while others keep things simple with an easy graham cracker crust.
There’s even a delicious sweet potato pie recipe, another classic Thanksgiving dessert that’s every bit as comforting as pumpkin.
Whether you’re baking for a large family celebration, bringing dessert to a work potluck, or preparing a cozy Sunday dinner during the fall season, these pie recipes offer something for every occasion and skill level.
From elegant holiday centerpieces to nostalgic family favorites, these 25 Thanksgiving pies make it easy to celebrate with homemade desserts that everyone will remember long after the last slice has disappeared.
25. Healthy Homemade Apple Pie (No-sugar, with Vegan Option)
Looking for a lighter dessert that still feels worthy of the Thanksgiving table? This wholesome apple pie lets the natural sweetness of fresh apples shine without adding refined sugar.
Every bite is packed with pure apple flavor, enhanced by a flaky crust made from convenient puff pastry. Preparing the filling is simple, with peeling and coring the apples being the only time-consuming step.
Unsalted butter creates a rich finish, while coconut butter makes this recipe an easy vegan-friendly option.
24. No-Bake Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie – Perfect Cream Cheese Pie for Thanksgiving!
This no-bake peanut butter pie is the ultimate dessert when you need something impressive with very little effort.
A crunchy Oreo crust holds a luscious filling made with creamy peanut butter, whipped topping, and rich cream cheese for an irresistibly smooth texture. Every slice is cool, fluffy, and loaded with chocolate-peanut butter flavor.
Since there’s no oven required, it’s a fantastic make-ahead dessert for Thanksgiving, holiday gatherings, or whenever you need a guaranteed crowd-pleaser.
23. Toffee Almond Pie vs Classic Pumpkin Pie
If pecan pie is a holiday tradition in your home, this almond version deserves a spot on your dessert table. It delivers the same rich, buttery filling and crisp topping while swapping pecans for sliced almonds, which create a lighter, more delicate crunch.
The real surprise comes from sweet toffee bits folded into the filling, adding pockets of caramel flavor throughout the pie. It’s an easy twist on a Thanksgiving classic that’s both familiar and refreshingly different.
22. Gingersnap Cranberry Key Lime Pie
Bright, colorful, and bursting with flavor, this cranberry key lime pie is anything but ordinary. The crust combines crushed gingersnaps, walnuts, butter, and brown sugar for a warmly spiced base that requires no rolling.
A homemade cranberry preserve is blended into a silky lime curd, creating a filling that’s perfectly balanced between sweet and tart.
After chilling until set, the pie slices beautifully and makes a stunning centerpiece for Thanksgiving or any festive holiday gathering.
21. Flavorful Sweet Potato Sour Cream Pie
Sweet potato pie is every bit as comforting as pumpkin pie, with a naturally rich flavor that’s easy to love. Roasting the sweet potatoes until tender intensifies their sweetness before they’re blended into a silky filling.
A generous spoonful of sour cream adds a subtle tang while making the texture extra creamy, much like a cheesecake. Warm spices round everything out, creating a dessert that’s smooth, flavorful, and perfect for cozy fall celebrations.
20. Dulce De Leche Pumpkin Pie Recipe with Caramel Flavor
Take traditional pumpkin pie to the next level by replacing sweetened condensed milk with luscious dulce de leche.
This simple upgrade creates the same creamy consistency while adding deep caramel notes that perfectly complement the pumpkin and warm spices. The filling bakes into a silky, rich dessert that’s guaranteed to impress guests.
For an extra-special finish, sprinkle a layer of crunchy pecan praline over the top before serving for irresistible texture and flavor.
19. Honey Pie – The Best Thanksgiving Pie!
Honey transforms this classic custard pie into something truly memorable. Instead of relying solely on sugar, the filling is naturally sweetened with fragrant honey, giving every bite delicate floral notes and incredible depth of flavor.
The smooth, creamy texture practically melts in your mouth, making it difficult to stop at one slice.
Serve it with whipped cream and a handful of honey-glazed walnuts for added crunch, and you’ll have an elegant Thanksgiving dessert everyone will remember.
18. Apple Cheddar Pie – The Best Recipe for Thanksgiving!
The combination of apples and cheddar may sound unusual, but one bite will quickly change your mind.
Sharp cheddar is incorporated into the buttery crust and lightly scattered throughout the apple filling, adding a subtle savory contrast to the fruit’s natural sweetness. The result is a perfectly balanced pie that’s rich, flaky, sweet, and slightly tangy all at once.
It’s a classic pairing that has stood the test of time for very good reason.
17. Spiced Plum Perfect Pie
This gorgeous plum pie brings vibrant color and bold flavor to any holiday dessert table. Juicy plums are tossed with warming spices before being arranged inside a flaky vegan crust, where they soften and caramelize as the pie bakes.
There’s no need to blind-bake the pastry, making the recipe surprisingly simple despite its elegant appearance. Serve each slice with dairy-free spiced whipped cream for a beautiful vegan dessert that’s every bit as satisfying as traditional pies.
16. Simple Salted Caramel Apple Pie Recipe
Classic apple pie is already a holiday favorite, but adding salted caramel makes it completely irresistible. As the pie bakes, the caramel melts into the apple filling, creating a rich sauce that thickens beautifully as it cools.
Every slice is packed with tender fruit, buttery pastry, and sweet-salty goodness. If weaving a lattice crust feels too time-consuming, simply finish the pie with an easy three-ingredient crumble topping for a rustic dessert that’s just as delicious.
15. Cranberry-Chocolate Tart with Sweet and Smooth Mascarpone Filling
This elegant tart is well worth the wait. The vibrant cranberry layer needs several hours to fully set, but the result is a stunning dessert with incredible flavor and texture.
A crisp buttery crust is filled with silky mascarpone cream before being topped with the jewel-like cranberry filling. Finish everything with a generous shower of chocolate shavings for an impressive presentation.
Rich, tangy, and creamy, it’s a beautiful centerpiece for any Thanksgiving dessert spread.
14. Turkey ‘n’ Stuffing Thanksgiving Pie Recipe
Turn leftover Thanksgiving dinner into an entirely new meal with this hearty turkey and stuffing pie. The real star is the flavorful stuffing crust, which adds incredible texture and captures one of everyone’s favorite holiday sides.
The filling combines turkey with vegetables, gravy, and mushrooms, though it’s easy to customize using whatever leftovers you have. Brussels sprouts, roasted carrots, or green beans all work beautifully, making this recipe as practical as it is comforting.
13. Fantastic Caramelized Pear and Chocolate Tart
This elegant pear tart combines delicate fruit with rich chocolate for a dessert that’s both simple and sophisticated. Start with a homemade or store-bought pastry shell, baking it until crisp and golden.
Thinly sliced pears gently soften as they cook in a glossy caramel syrup, creating a tender, flavorful filling. Once cooled, everything is finished with a silky chocolate ganache that adds luxurious richness.
Every bite balances sweet fruit, buttery pastry, and decadent chocolate.
12. Leftover Thanksgiving Shepherd’s Pie with Mashed Potatoes
Don’t let your Thanksgiving leftovers go to waste when you can transform them into this comforting shepherd’s pie. Simply layer leftover turkey, stuffing, vegetables, and rich gravy into a baking dish before covering everything with fluffy mashed potatoes.
As it bakes, the filling becomes hot and bubbly while the potato topping turns beautifully golden. It’s an effortless way to enjoy holiday flavors all over again without feeling like you’re eating the exact same meal.
11. Elegant French-style Pear and Almond Tart
Few desserts look as refined as a classic French pear and almond tart. Sweet pears are nestled into a rich almond frangipane filling, then baked until beautifully golden before receiving a glossy apricot glaze.
For even more flavor, spread a thin layer of pear jam infused with green cardamom across the crust before adding the filling. The delicate spice enhances the fruit perfectly, creating an elegant dessert that’s ideal for holidays, brunches, or special occasions.
10. Sweet Potato Chiffon Pie vs Classic Sweet Potato Pie
If you love sweet potato pie but prefer lighter desserts, this chiffon version is the perfect compromise. It delivers all the familiar flavors of cinnamon, nutmeg, and creamy sweet potato while whipped egg whites create an incredibly airy texture.
The filling feels almost cloud-like compared to traditional pie, making it easier to enjoy after a large holiday meal. Just fold the egg whites in gently to keep the mixture light and beautifully fluffy.
9. Easy & Delicious Turkey Pot Pie (for Thanksgiving Leftover Meal)
Leftover turkey becomes something completely new in this comforting homemade pot pie. Tender turkey is combined with vegetables and creamy gravy before being tucked beneath a flaky golden crust that bakes to perfection.
Best of all, the recipe comes together in about ten minutes, making it ideal after a busy Thanksgiving celebration. Instead of serving the same leftovers day after day, this cozy pie transforms them into a hearty family meal everyone will happily enjoy again.
8. Bourbon Pecan Pie Recipe with Bacon
This indulgent pecan pie is everything you love about the classic dessert—with a smoky, savory twist. Rich bourbon deepens the caramel-like filling, while crispy bacon adds salty bites that perfectly balance the sweetness.
Toasted pecans create a satisfying crunch in every slice, making this pie wonderfully rich and full of texture. It’s definitely not a vegan dessert, but for bacon lovers, this unforgettable combination of sweet, smoky, and nutty flavors is hard to beat.
7. Ooey, Gooey, Sticky, and Sweet Oatmeal Rum Raisin Pie
If you love oatmeal raisin cookies, this pie takes those comforting flavors to a whole new level. Raisins soaked in rum become wonderfully plump and flavorful, while rolled oats add hearty texture throughout the filling.
During baking, the rich sugary mixture settles into a luscious caramel-like layer beneath a crisp oat topping. The contrast between the gooey center and crunchy surface makes every bite irresistible. Just be patient—it slices best after cooling completely.
6. Cinnamon-spiced Cheesecake Pie
Imagine everything you love about cheesecake combined with the cozy flavors of the holiday season.
This rich dessert features a silky cream cheese filling infused with generous amounts of cinnamon, creating an aroma that instantly fills the kitchen with festive warmth.
The creamy texture perfectly balances the bold spice, resulting in a dessert that’s decadent without feeling overwhelming. For an extra-special finish, drizzle each slice with salted caramel sauce or rich caramel ganache before serving.
5. Fall-favorite Salted Caramel Pumpkin Pie
Pumpkin pie is already a Thanksgiving essential, but salted caramel makes it even more unforgettable. Instead of simply drizzling caramel over the finished dessert, this recipe folds it directly into the creamy pumpkin filling for deeper flavor in every bite.
Warm autumn spices complement the rich caramel beautifully, creating a silky pie that’s comforting, festive, and wonderfully indulgent. Add homemade bourbon salted caramel on top if you really want to impress your holiday guests.
4. Cranberry Orange Custard Pie (Perfect Homemade Flaky Pie Crust!)
Bright cranberries and sweet orange custard come together in this refreshing twist on traditional holiday pie. Tart fresh cranberries provide bursts of vibrant flavor, while the silky citrus custard softens their sharpness with creamy sweetness.
Even better, the filling bakes directly inside the pie shell, eliminating the need to blind-bake the crust first. The result is an elegant dessert that’s colorful, creamy, and a welcome change from the usual pumpkin and pecan pies.
3. Gingersnap Crumb Pear Pie with Lemon Juice
Tender pears tossed with fresh lemon juice create a delicate fruit filling that’s both sweet and bright. But the real star of this pie is the buttery gingersnap crumble topping, which bakes into a crisp, spiced layer full of warm holiday flavor.
Brown sugar and butter create a texture somewhere between streusel and shortbread, adding irresistible crunch to every bite. It’s a comforting dessert that beautifully showcases pears during the fall and winter months.
2. Rustic and Delicious Cranberry Apple Slab Pie
If traditional pies make you nervous, this rustic slab pie is the perfect solution. Instead of worrying about flawless edges or decorative lattice work, simply roll out the dough and let its homemade appearance shine.
Sweet apples and tart cranberries create a vibrant filling that’s bursting with seasonal flavor, while the crisp pastry turns beautifully golden in the oven. It’s easier to prepare, simpler to serve at gatherings, and every bit as delicious as a classic apple pie.
1. Butternut Squash Pie – Pretty Thanksgiving Dessert
Butternut squash makes a wonderful alternative to traditional pumpkin pie, offering a similarly creamy texture with a slightly sweeter, nuttier flavor.
It’s often easier to find than large pumpkins and requires much less preparation, making holiday baking a little more convenient.
Blended with warm spices, the squash transforms into a silky, velvety filling that’s every bit as comforting as the classic version. Serve each slice with whipped cream or vanilla ice cream for a beautiful Thanksgiving dessert everyone will love.
25 Best Thanksgiving Pie Recipes to Impress Guests
Elevate your perfect Thanksgiving dessert! Find the 25 best Thanksgiving pie recipes, including classic apple, pumpkin, and pecan pies, plus tips for the perfect pie crust.
Ingredients
- No-sugar Homemade Apple Pie with Vegan Option
- No-Bake Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
- Toffee Almond Pie
- Gingersnap Cranberry Lime Pie
- Sweet Potato Sour Cream Pie
- Dulce De Leche Pumpkin Pie
- Honey Pie
- Apple Cheddar Pie
- Spiced Plum Pie
- Salted Caramel Apple Pie
- Cranberry-Chocolate Tart
- Turkey ‘n’ Stuffing Pie
- Caramelized Pear and Chocolate Tart
- Leftover Thanksgiving Shepherd’s Pie
- Pear and Almond Tart
- Sweet Potato Chiffon Pie
- Super Easy & Delicious Turkey Pot Pie
- Bourbon Bacon Pecan Pie
- Oatmeal Rum Raisin Pie
- Cinnamon Pie
- Salted Caramel Pumpkin Pie
- Cranberry Orange Custard Pie
- Gingersnap Crumb Pear Pie
- Cranberry Apple Slab Pie
- Butternut Squash Pie
Instructions
- Choose any Thanksgiving Pie Recipes from the post that you like.
- Click on the link below the photo to get the full recipes and instructions.
- Try the best Thanksgiving Pie Recipes and share your photo under my pin on Pinterest!
I share healthy recipes, clean eating ideas, and meal plans for weight loss, as well as give you the best tips on wellness, pregnancy, and parenting advice.